IT Solutions

Mastering Incident Response Drills: Best Practices & Key Metrics

Articles
May 19, 2025

Ransomware and AI-driven attacks are still some of the biggest dangers businesses face, and these cyber threats are only getting smarter. Preparing your organization to respond effectively to a cybersecurity incident is just as important as prevention. One of the most reliable ways to build this readiness is through incident response drills.

Running drills helps prepare your team to know what to do, when to do it, and how to minimize damage, whether you’re dealing with ransomware, insider threats, or a potential data breach.

Telehealth Technology Guide

Is your organization prepared for Windows 10 EOL?
Explore our free guide to plan your next move with confidence:


Don’t Wait. Migrate with ITS: Your Guide to Windows 10 EOL.

What Are Incident Response Drills?

Incident response drills are simulated cybersecurity scenarios that test your organization’s response preparedness. They are designed to help identify weaknesses, clarify roles and responsibilities, and refine response processes before a real event occurs.

  • Tabletop Exercises: These low-impact, discussion-based walk-throughs of hypothetical cyber incidents are often the best starting point. None of the organization’s systems are impacted, and they help teams identify gaps in communication, decision-making, and knowledge of the incident response plan.
  • Functional Drills: Functional drills include hands-on testing of specific systems, processes, and tools. They are ideal for giving advanced teams real-time experience without impacting day-to-day operations.
  • Full-Scale Simulations: These high-intensity drills recreate real incidents, engaging every part of your cyber threat response team—technical, legal, executive, and sometimes external partners—to give everyone an immersive experience in real time.

There isn’t a one-size-fits-all drill. Each type of drill provides unique, actionable insights. Choose the format that aligns with your organization’s needs, goals, and available resources.

What Makes a Drill Effective?

Every successful incident response drill starts with a defined structure followed by purposeful execution and review. At a minimum, you’ll want to include the following:

Clearly Defined Roles and Responsibilities

Each participant should fully understand their role, how it impacts fellow team members, and the project as a whole. In a live incident, clear responsibilities reduce confusion when time matters most. For example:

  • Who’s in charge?
  • Who communicates with clients or the media?
  • Who restores affected systems?

Up-to-Date Documentation

Your organization’s incident response plan should be a living document. Drills are the perfect opportunity to test how well your current protocols work and identify areas that need updating.

  • Regularly review your incident response plan.
  • Include and keep current communication templates, checklists, and contact trees.

Realistic Scenarios

Whether you’re testing for a phishing attack, ransomware outbreak, or internal threat, the more realistic the scenario, the more valuable the outcome.

  • Create exercises that involve threats you’re likely to face.
  • Use recent trends and intelligence to make scenarios more relevant.

Getting Started with Tabletop Exercises

Tabletop exercises are the practical solution if you’re just starting to document and formalize your incident response systems. The guided discussions walk team members through an incident step-by-step, encouraging collaboration and quick thinking in a safe environment.

What to Expect:

  • It’s all scenario-based, so no systems are affected.
  • Participants leave the experience with lessons learned without risking downtime.

Best Practices:

  • Keep the exercise structured yet flexible enough for honest discussion.
  • Invite all key departments to participate, including IT, legal, HR, communications, and executive leadership.
  • Document everything, especially action items and next steps, and share with the team.

When your teams are ready, further familiarize them with your organization’s cyber threat responses by practicing with functional drills.

When It’s Time for Full-Scale Simulations

After your teams have gained satisfactory competence with the basics, consider running more advanced, full-scale simulations testing everything from technical response to internal communications. These drills will give you a benchmark for how well your teams collaborate, escalate incidents, and communicate with leadership while under pressure. It’s also an opportunity to test your cybersecurity tools in a practice scenario.

Why Go Full-Scale?

  • Test integrations between your EDR (Endpoint Detection and Response), SIEM (Security Information and Event Management), and other tools.
  • Evaluate how your team responds in real time under pressure.
  • Engage vendors or third parties if they’re part of your incident response ecosystem.

Measuring Success: Metrics and Continuous Improvement

Incident response drills are necessary as you prepare your team to respond to cyber threats. They’re also a diagnostic tool to help teams identify strengths, weaknesses, and opportunities to improve. 

After each drill, we help clients conduct a structured review while reviewing key metrics such as:

  • Time to detect and respond/escalate the incident
  • Communication accuracy and escalation timelines
  • Speed of containment and recovery
  • Quality of documentation and decision-making
  • Policy and documentation gaps
  • User and entity behavior analytics findings

The real value of incident response drills isn’t just testing your plan—it’s using what you learn to build faster, smarter, and more resilient responses in the future.

Ready to Strengthen Your Response Strategy?

At IT Solutions, we help organizations run incident response drills that reflect real-world risks, tailored to your industry, internal workflows, and compliance requirements. Whether you’re in healthcare, legal, or finance, we design exercises that surface blind spots, improve coordination, and strengthen your team’s ability to act fast under pressure.

From tabletop scenarios to full-scale simulations, we handle the planning, facilitation, and follow-up—so you’re not just testing a plan, but building a stronger one.

With ITS in your corner, you’re not just prepared, you’re positioned to respond confidently.

Contact us to learn more or schedule an industry-specific response drill.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • How do I gain executive buy-in for conducting incident response drills?

    • Emphasize that incident response drills aren’t just a security checkbox—they’re a business continuity strategy. Drills help reduce risk, minimize costly downtime, and ensure compliance with evolving regulations.
  • Does organization size or industry affect how drills are planned?

    • Absolutely. We adjust scope, scenarios, and goals to match your specific risks and regulatory requirements..
  • Can we combine physical and cyber elements in a drill?
    • Yes, and we recommend it. Today’s attacks often blend digital and physical tactics, whether a phishing email leads to unauthorized badge access or a stolen device that grants internal system access. Simulating both elements in your drill helps ensure your response plan accounts for real-world complexities, like coordination between IT and facilities teams, secure communication during lockdown scenarios, or insider threats that cross physical boundaries.
  • What happens if a drill uncovers serious weaknesses?

    • It may sound counterintuitive, but if your systems have significant weaknesses, you want to know about them before a real incident occurs. We work with you to prioritize fixes, roll out safeguards, and update your employee training.
  • How can we run a drill without disrupting business operations?
    • We often use after-hours sessions or test environments to limit disruptions.
  • Can remote teams participate effectively?
    • We use secure collaboration platforms so distributed teams can fully engage, regardless of location. 

Have Questions?

We’ve got answers — fast, clear, and tailored to your needs. Let’s talk tech.